3 August 2020

Battle rages in divorce cases over ‘custody of much loved pets’

Divorce and separation can be a challenging time with the pressures of child arrangements and the division of the financial assets but one area that is becoming increasingly acrimonious is custody of the couple’s much loved pets

It has become a growing trend for pets to become a part of the process with both parties wanting custody of them.  Dogs and cats top the list but it is not unusual to see smaller or more exotic animals included.

Pets are regarded as chattels in divorce proceedings (England and Wales) which means they form part of the property of the couple. Therefore, if a dispute surrounds the animal and the parties cannot reach a resolution the court can decide who should keep the pet.

However, in America in the past three years, three states have changed their divorce statutes to treat pets more as family members than as chattel to be divided.  Nowadays, 80% of owners view their pets as family members, according to a survey by the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA)

If it is left to the courts to decide ‘custody of the pet’ both parties present evidence in support of their case to the court.  To reach a decision the court may try to determine ownership by looking at who registered the pet with either the Kennel Club or whose name is on the microchip database. They may also look at what is in the best interest of the pet and cause the least disruption although it does not have a duty to do so in the same way as it does with children.

It is often the case that it will simply be left with the party it currently resides with at the moment but if the pet is a dog they are likely to consider the parties working arrangements to ensure they are not putting it with someone who is at work all day if that would result in the dog spending many hours on its own with little exercise.

An important factor to take into account before entering into a protracted court battle is whether the animal is a family pet and children are involved.  Many children form a special bond with their pets and it forms an important part of their lives.  They will already be experiencing disruption and possible upset by the circumstances surrounding the divorce and removing the pet from their home would be likely to cause increased upset.

There have been many high profile cases recently with celebrities fighting for ownership and it is becoming increasingly popular to include pets in Pre-Nuptial agreements to avoid court battles.

In a court battle in America lasting 2 years and costing $15000 the applicant had said when his ex-wife decided he could no longer see their two dogs “It tortured me” “In our whole divorce, that was the only thing that could hurt me”.  At the end of the process he was granted access to see the dogs.

If you would like further information on the above or any aspect of family law contact Spectrum Family Law on 01279 799598 or email contact@spectrumfamilylaw.com.